Best Pizza in Manorville

Taste the Perfect Blend of Pizza and Italian Cuisine

Order Online

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Regular Cheese Pizza (18")

Classic cheese or create your own pizza

Add Item

BBQ Chicken Pizza (18")

Topped with BBQ sauce, mozzarella, and chicken meat

Add Item

Vegan Dairy Free Pizza (18")

Our same pizza dough but instead topped with our red sauce and Daiya, dairy-free mozzarella

Add Item

Chicken Wings (6 Pieces)

Homemade chicken wings with your choice of plain, buffalo or bbq sauce served with blue cheese and a side of celery

Add Item

Fried Calamari

Floured and deep-fried calamari served with lemon and marinara sauce

Add Item

Mussels

Served in your choice of a red sauce or a white sauce

Add Item

Pennachio's Salad

Mesclun salad with roasted walnuts, sliced pears, goat cheese, and plum tomatoes with raspberry vinaigrette

Add Item

Spaghetti with Meatballs (Pasta)

Spaghetti topped with 3 of our homemade meatballs and topped in a delicious red sauce

Add Item

Grilled Chicken & Veggies (Entree)

Grilled chicken with sauteed mixed vegetables

Add Item

Welcome To Pennachio's Restaurant & Pizzeria

Pennachio's Restaurant & Pizzeria was founded in 2017, and is a family-owned restaurant and pizzeria located in Manorville, NY. We use only the freshest ingredients for the preparation of our food. When food is prepared with love and pride, the product speaks for itself. We carry many of your favorite Italian specialties and take requests from our visitors! Wine served by the glass or bottle. Reservations available. Delivery to Manorville, Eastport and parts of Moriches.

Treat Your Taste Buds

Savor one of our voluminous entrees, a fresh salad or one of our delicious pizza pies- ALL guaranteed to satisfy your tastebuds.

Explore Our Menu

Dig Into Flavor-Packed Portions

Our portions are very generous so that our customers get the “bang for their buck” when dining out or ordering takeout. We offer a wide selection of entrees which includes carne, eggplant, chicken, pasta and seafood dishes along with salads, heroes, wraps, and much more. Most of our salad dressings are homemade as well as all of our dessert options such as cheesecake, chocolate layer cake, Tiramisu and cannoli’s.

Dive In Now

Discover Gluten Free/Vegan Options

We have gluten-free options (personal sized pizza pie, penne pasta, and gluten-free flour). Also, we have vegan, gluten free dairy free cheese to replace mozzarella cheese on heroes or pizza and gluten free flour for some entrees.

Enjoy A Balanced Meal

Order From Our Website

Enjoy the convenience of Pennachio’s Restaurant & Pizzeria! Order online and indulge in our flavorful pizzas, entrees, salads, and more, all from the comfort of your home. With gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegan options, there’s something for everyone. Browse our menu and have your favorites delivered straight to your door. Order now!

Order Now

Savor the Flavor – Explore Our Gallery

Indulge in the vibrant dishes of Pennachio’s, from hearty entrees to mouthwatering pizzas and desserts, all captured in our photo gallery.

Flavors That Make You Feel At Home

At Pennachio’s Restaurant & Pizzeria, we bring you a delicious blend of classic Italian dishes and modern favorites. From our generous portions of entrees and fresh salads to our handcrafted pizzas, each dish is made with care and the finest ingredients. Whether you’re dining in or ordering takeout, experience the taste of quality and tradition with every bite. Join us for a meal that feels like home.

Event Catering

Whether it's your office party or a small family get-together, we can provide you with top-class catering services. Rely on Pennachio's to fulfill your guest and your appetite with exceptional Italian cuisine. On premise and off premise catering available.

Cater With Us

Host Your Next Event At Pennachio’s

Make your celebration special by hosting it at Pennachio’s. From intimate dinners to large gatherings, our space is perfect for any occasion.

Book Your Event

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

I recently moved to Manorville and tried Pennachio’s. The buffalo chicken slice was amazing—thick chicken in a perfectly spicy sauce, with crust so good you'd eat it even without the toppings. The pie was fantastic too! My new go-to pizza spot! See you soon!

Bill M.

I visited to sample dishes for a wedding catering order and was thrilled! The sauce was fresh, and the quality was top-notch. We had eggplant parm, chicken parm, bolognese, pasta primavera, and chicken francese—all perfectly cooked. Excited for our event!

Theresa R.

Wow!!! We just ordered delivery - Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Parm Dinner & Angel Hair Shrimp & Crab Meat - everything was amazing!!! Loved every bite! Highly recommended!